Ficarella`s Pizzeria in Batavia

They think red hot is meat hot sauce on trash plates. Had issues getting it right. Management was rude as can be. Told me it costs them money cause they messed up a order. Horrible place to order from.

Horrible food I get sick every time we order the chicken wings are not cooked all the way even when they r told to double fry them

My family and I were staying at a hotel in Batavia. We wanted pizza. We waited over an hour and a half for pizza and and wings. When I called the lady on the phone was so rude and said what would you like to do we have other orders also. Not a way you run a business.

The best veggie sub I have ever had and reasonably priced.

One of the Greatest Sheet Pizzas on the Planet! Subs are killer and the best fish fry aroun😋A local Gem!

The absolute best apple logs!!

I have tried 99% of restaurants in Batavia with Chicken Wings and this place is in my top 2. Super good and probably one of the best wings out here.

WOULD NOT RECOMMEND! FYI LOOK AT HOW THE "OWNER" REPLIES TO CRITICISM OF THEIR POOR PRODUCT AND POOR SERVICE (you wont have to scroll very far).........PROOF IS IN THE PUDDING ...

The food use to be good. Asked for extra cheese on a sheet pizza with extra mushrooms on half and extra pepperoni on the other half. but instead I got a sh!t pizza with normal toppings and bland raw wings when I asked for mild well done. I payed 70$ never again. I payed for 2” of dough and toppings just thrown on top..... so disappointed

I called to order a veal sub, but the person that answered the phone seemed quite clueless on how to take an order. I specifically asked for it to have pizza sauce on it instead of pasta sauce on it as the pasta sauce is horrible. I received my sub, but it had only about 2 tablespoons of sauce on the large sub, very small amount of cheese, and the sauce was wrong. I called back to complain and I was told that I didn't know what I was talking about. They refused to fix my order. I would leave a 0 star review, but the site wouldn't give me that option. I'll order elsewhere from now on.

It's good pizza and reasonably priced. The wings need some help.

Ordered a large cheese and pepperoni pizza was so greasy and wet all the topping were sliding right off and couldn't even eat it it was horrible

Ordered a Greek salad with blue cheese dressing, buffalo chicken wrap, cheeseburger wrap, and spaghetti with meatballs. Spaghetti with meatballs with canned sauce the meatballs were cold and Frozen the cheeseburger wrap had a half a patty in it that tasted like rubber the chicken wrap was nothing but vegetables and maybe one chicken finger the only good thing was the salad Im giving Stars just because the service was good; the girl behind the counter was very nice .... Paid 60.00 for the not good at all food and a morning in the bathroom not feeling so good Needless to say Will not recommend or go back

Very poor service sending out wrong order. I hope calls are recorded you will see your mistake. I checked the rankings for pizza parlors. Ficarella's #7 behind places like Domino's and Mark's, those agree pizza chains. Shame on you ficarella's...FYI: no need credits toward future orders

Worst g plate I’ve ever had! Called and ordered two identical plates. Cheeseburger, homies, Mac fully loaded. My coworkers was perfect, they even added a scoop of baked beans(not all places do) mine was a bowl of mustard and franks red hot soup. No beans no meat sauce no ketchup. Three out of the other four orders that were with that were wrong too.

Staff is amazing. Food is always out of this world, thanks to Nick and everyone else there!

First time ordering from this place. I'm not very happy with this place at all. The pizza had no flavor wings were not very tasty at all. Prices are very high and you wait double the time with alot of the people waiting complaining. 70 dollars for wing and a pizza.

Love the bread, this was a great sub and the drive thru really makes after work pickups super smooth.

Ficarellas is the best pizza joint in Batavia for Calzones. Service is fast and polite, and I've never had a bad meal here.

Always great pizza👍

Professional and friendly staff and great food and portions.

Best wings in Batavia and they Make my wings the way I want them , trust me I tried them all and the other joints won’t even give me all flats .. I’m paying for them so I should get what i want !

Placed order box said our address for the wrong thing it was pizza rather than the calzone Soni called and I heard the girl on the phone tell this lady said she got a pizza instead of her calzone. So then they said they would remake it fine got the remake and the calzone consisted of pepperoni and mushrooms and Moz cheese no ricota that is why I ordered a.calzone instead of pizza. The last few other times we ordered pizza crust has been burnt on the bottom to the point my husband and I are the toppings and not the crust. Just moved out this way and first time was excellent wonder what's upAntipasto salad is excellent really enjoyed it it was huge

Pizza was great, but the boneless wings were AMAZING!! I'll definitely be back! Plus, they have a drive thru!!

Amazing food. I get their Chicken wings or chicken finger subs.

This is the best pizza in Batavia!

Reminisce the way pizza is supposed to taste. Portion sizes for land locked giants and hungry patrons. Staff were very friendly and even referred other restaurants in the area for other cuisine options. I was immediately taken back to memory lane for northeast pizzerias that bring you in from the cold and warm you up with cheesy and freshly baked crust. Pepperonis were real and sausage was super flavorful. I will visit again and bring the wife as she loves Italian cuisine 👍

Love their pizza. I live 2 hours away and every time I’m in Batavia, I take a pizza back with me.